Enough, the Community Association Institute doesn't represent Homeowners Associations (HOAs) or HOA home owners. This organization represents the interests of HOA property managers (PMs) and the legal industry involved in HOA governance and representing HOA Boards in court. No problem with this but the press, AARP, the legislature, and the general media get it all wrong. In fact, the CAI is known among home owner advocacy groups as a mostly anti-home owner organization.
The Denver Post in the past months has published articles on the topic of construction defects and HOAs and the right of home owners to vote on the use of HOA funds prior to the HOA Board entering into costly and potentially financially devastating law suits. The articles misleadingly indicated the CAI represents home owners and HOA organizations. No evidence exists of any HOA organization or their organizing home owners to protect their interests. The CAI opposed any mandate to have home owners vote on the use of their own funds in law suits. Is this pro home owners?
Then there was the CAI's recent opposition to ending/limiting the HOA home sale Transfer Fee that has never been justified and is illegal on all home sales except in HOAs (wonder who got that exception into legislation?). This fee lines the pockets of PMs (not HOAs), costs HOA home owners millions each year, and a PM can charge amounts ranging from $50 to $1150 for like services and the fee can't be negotiated by the home owner (and if not paid the home sale is held up). Does this sound like they represent home owners? Examples abound and can found on our web site www.coloradohoaforum.com
One final thought on this. For the past decades the CAI in Colorado has been the primary if not the sole source on issues of HOA governance, home owner rights, and in writing HOA legislation. They promoted their professionalism, altruism, and oversight of the HOA PM industry and were recognized leaders to our legislators. As a result of their "leadership" and the thousands of PM related home owner complaints received by legislators and the State HOA Office, legislation was passed to clean up the PM industry. Doesn't sound like leadership or protecting HOA home owner rights?
So enough of the CAI misrepresentation. The press and our law makers should seek out the opinions of HOA home owners (organizations) in HOA issues and not simply default to those who profit and have the interests of PMs and lawyers as their focus.
Thursday, October 16, 2014
Tuesday, October 14, 2014
Colorado Construction Defects Issue is an HOA Issue
A construction defects Bill was introduced to the Colorado legislature last session. It got caught up in the legislative process (purposely) and never got voted upon. The issue is back. It touches directly on home owner rights and limiting the ability of an HOA Board to spend HOA funds on law suits without the knowledge of, awareness of, or approval (via a vote) of home owners. Below is the most current correspondence issued by the Colorado HOA Forum www.coloradohoaforum.com to State legislators and to our members. Colorado is not alone in home owners pursuing legislative reform on limiting the authority of HOA Boards. I can't go without apprising you of the fact that the Community Association Institute (CAI) opposes our recommended legislation (it would greatly reduce the opportunity for litigation).
--------------------------------------------
To our members:
The below was sent to all legislators. A construction defects Bill will
most likely again be worked on in the next legislative session. Our perspective
on this is to protect home owners from bankrupting and/or using HOA funds on law
suits when home owners are not aware of, provided justification of, or approve
of such actions. This would also allow litigation in construction defects when
approved of by home owners. Note, the CAI, whose interests with the legal
industry, objects to our proposed legislative Bill and appears to promote law
suits over home owner's rights.
To legislators:
The issue of construction defects litigation is directly impacting on HOA
legislative reform. The Denver Post's most recent article on this issue prompted our
below letter to the editor. We know that a Bill that would limit the authority
and ability of HOA Boards to embark on costly law suits without the knowledge,
awareness, and approval of home owners would resolve many construction defects
litigation issues. It would not preclude legal action but require home owners,
who pay the tariff, to make decisions on these costly and potentially
financially disastrous. It would seem to satisfy the want of the construction
industry and protect and empower home owners. This HOA legislative reform is
needed regardless of construction defects. I ask your sponsorship for such a
Bill should you continue to serve in the State legislature. Thank you.
Email to Denver Post:
Construction defects litigation proposals hit at the core of problems in
Homeowners Association (HOA) governance. Passing legislation to empower HOA
home owners by limiting the ability of an HOA Board to use HOA funds for legal
actions without their approval will be a win-win on this topic. HOA Boards can
(legally) embark on costly law suits without justifying or informing home owners
of their intentions and without their approval. Legal costs have financially
drained and/or bankrupted many HOA's. HOA legal actions can and have resulted
in draining HOA reserve funds and costly special assessments on home
owners. Opposition to limiting HOA Board authority comes from the legal
community and the Community Association Institute (CAI). Their
constituents prosper with an ability to access HOA funds to pay for costly
litigation without having to "bother" with home owner approval. Legislation to
limit HOA Board authority in spending on legal actions would empower and protect
home owners from costly, baseless, and home owner "unsupported" legal cases.
Such a Bill would not preclude legal actions (in construction defects and other
areas) but ensure that those who pay the tariff, the home owner, know who is
spending their money, on what, and how much.
Thursday, October 9, 2014
Why HOA State Law and Governing Documents are (not) enforceable
There are plenty of definitive and comprehensive State HOA laws. HOAs have their own governing documents defining controls, covenants, and restrictions. HOA Boards ensure compliance of covenants through their authority by issuing fines, court actions, and/or foreclosing on property for unpaid fees, fines and special assessments: This is part of living under HOA governance and home owners must understand the HOA governing documents were developed with the intention of enforcement.
Now that takes care of enforcement of home owner compliance. What about when an HOA Board violates the governing documents or even State HOA law? The rules of enforcement change and home owners begin to understand that enforcement may be a one way street and they are running into oncoming traffic. The only means of enforcement from the home owner's perspective is our costly, litigious, and time consuming court system. Most home owners simply can't afford or compete with the unlimited funds of the HOA and their paid attorneys in even the most simple court case. Yes, lawyers are allowed in Small Claims court. Furthermore, if the home owner loses they most likely will pay the HOA legal costs. Under the current environment of HOA litigation most home owners quickly understand that the cost of pursuing a violation by their Board, management company, or HOA attorney far outweigh the benefits and their chances of justice in a "pay to play" court system preclude pursuing their complaint.
HOA home owner complaints simply don't belong in our court system. They mostly involve violations of HOA governing documents and when pursuing financial losses the amounts are low. The cases are not complicated and should not require lawyers. Such cases unnecessarily add to court work load and costs. What is needed, and has been endorsed by a State sanctioned study on HOA dispute resolution, is the implementation of an out of court binding dispute resolution process. This venue is affordable, accessible, and provides an environment in which facts and fairness trump financial resources. It is also a process that is easy to understand, is expedient and simply involves filing a complaint with the State, the complaint is vetted for substance, and a hearing is completed by a State sanctioned med-arb (mediator with arbiter (decision making) authority) trained in HOA law. If the parties in the complaint can't come to a binding agreement the med-arb will make the binding decision. In affect, this is what happens in a court venue: someone, the judge, makes a decision and it is enforceable. The process has a beginning and end all out of court and affordable. Placing this process into law only awaits legislative sponsors (and overcoming objections from the Community Association Institute (CAI) and lawyers who profit by HOA court actions).
Now that takes care of enforcement of home owner compliance. What about when an HOA Board violates the governing documents or even State HOA law? The rules of enforcement change and home owners begin to understand that enforcement may be a one way street and they are running into oncoming traffic. The only means of enforcement from the home owner's perspective is our costly, litigious, and time consuming court system. Most home owners simply can't afford or compete with the unlimited funds of the HOA and their paid attorneys in even the most simple court case. Yes, lawyers are allowed in Small Claims court. Furthermore, if the home owner loses they most likely will pay the HOA legal costs. Under the current environment of HOA litigation most home owners quickly understand that the cost of pursuing a violation by their Board, management company, or HOA attorney far outweigh the benefits and their chances of justice in a "pay to play" court system preclude pursuing their complaint.
HOA home owner complaints simply don't belong in our court system. They mostly involve violations of HOA governing documents and when pursuing financial losses the amounts are low. The cases are not complicated and should not require lawyers. Such cases unnecessarily add to court work load and costs. What is needed, and has been endorsed by a State sanctioned study on HOA dispute resolution, is the implementation of an out of court binding dispute resolution process. This venue is affordable, accessible, and provides an environment in which facts and fairness trump financial resources. It is also a process that is easy to understand, is expedient and simply involves filing a complaint with the State, the complaint is vetted for substance, and a hearing is completed by a State sanctioned med-arb (mediator with arbiter (decision making) authority) trained in HOA law. If the parties in the complaint can't come to a binding agreement the med-arb will make the binding decision. In affect, this is what happens in a court venue: someone, the judge, makes a decision and it is enforceable. The process has a beginning and end all out of court and affordable. Placing this process into law only awaits legislative sponsors (and overcoming objections from the Community Association Institute (CAI) and lawyers who profit by HOA court actions).
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
Colorado HOA Forum Begins it's Legislative Initiative
The Colorado HOA Forum has begun its' efforts on HOA legislative reform for the 2014-15 legislative session. Our approach on changing Colorado HOA law is to gain legislative sponsors for our proposed initiatives through email and telephone campaigns, meeting with our law makers in person, and getting media coverage to promote our efforts. Emails and notices sent to our legislators and the media.
We again will face the opposition of the Community Association Institute (CAI), legal community, and property managers in our efforts. These are very well funded lobbyist with a history of obstructing HOA reform and they have many legislators in support of their self serving agenda. Home owner groups must continue in their efforts to dispel the belief in State legislatures that the CAI somehow represents home owner interests: this is the current environment. Once legislators consider home owner organizations opinions and initiatives equal to those of the CAI we can begin to implement HOA reform.
We encourage HOA home owner organizations and individuals in Colorado and throughout the U.S. to continue lobbying their legislators and the media on the need for HOA reform.
We again will face the opposition of the Community Association Institute (CAI), legal community, and property managers in our efforts. These are very well funded lobbyist with a history of obstructing HOA reform and they have many legislators in support of their self serving agenda. Home owner groups must continue in their efforts to dispel the belief in State legislatures that the CAI somehow represents home owner interests: this is the current environment. Once legislators consider home owner organizations opinions and initiatives equal to those of the CAI we can begin to implement HOA reform.
We encourage HOA home owner organizations and individuals in Colorado and throughout the U.S. to continue lobbying their legislators and the media on the need for HOA reform.
Saturday, September 13, 2014
HOA Transfer Fees Still Burden Home Owners
HOA Transfer Fees will continue to financially burden HOA home owners despite new disclosure guidelines in the Colorado HOA property manager (Community Association Manager, CAM) licensing Bill effective July 2015. This is a fee imposed on home sellers to subsidize the CAM industry, is not mandated by law, and funds are retained by the CAM not the HOA. The fee, ranging from $100 to over $1,000 has never been justified by work performed, must be paid or the home sale can't be completed, and is not negotiable in amount (it's whatever the CAM decides, no if's, and's, or but's). The cost to Colorado HOA home owners is over $10 million a year and nationwide the tab runs to several hundred million dollars a year.
Colorado began a road to reform on this fee with the introduction of a Bill in 2014 to limit the fee in amount, require CAMs to justify the reason and amount of fee, and show how they were not already compensated for all Transfer Fee work in their contract with the HOA (which to date they have never done). The Community Association Institute (CAI) effectively killed the Bill and our legislators allowed them to re-write the Bill to preclude any dollar limits, negotiation of fees, or require justification and itemized disclosure of amounts charged. Instead, HOA home owners got the issue pushed to the CAM licensing guidelines in the form of "requesting" the fee be disclosed ensuring nothing will change and it will continue to be a "pay it or you can't sell" situation. The detail of disclosure can be a one liner "Transfer Fee" on a closing statement with no specific explanation or justification. Also tacitly supporting this abusive fee was the Colorado Association of Realtors who refused to take a stand on the fee to help the folks who put bread on their plates: home sellers and buyers.
Our organization, Colorado HOA Forum, will again in 2014-2105 seek legislative sponsors to limit or end this fee. The CAI will also be there to peddle their influence and kill any home owner efforts to end/limit this fee.
Colorado began a road to reform on this fee with the introduction of a Bill in 2014 to limit the fee in amount, require CAMs to justify the reason and amount of fee, and show how they were not already compensated for all Transfer Fee work in their contract with the HOA (which to date they have never done). The Community Association Institute (CAI) effectively killed the Bill and our legislators allowed them to re-write the Bill to preclude any dollar limits, negotiation of fees, or require justification and itemized disclosure of amounts charged. Instead, HOA home owners got the issue pushed to the CAM licensing guidelines in the form of "requesting" the fee be disclosed ensuring nothing will change and it will continue to be a "pay it or you can't sell" situation. The detail of disclosure can be a one liner "Transfer Fee" on a closing statement with no specific explanation or justification. Also tacitly supporting this abusive fee was the Colorado Association of Realtors who refused to take a stand on the fee to help the folks who put bread on their plates: home sellers and buyers.
Our organization, Colorado HOA Forum, will again in 2014-2105 seek legislative sponsors to limit or end this fee. The CAI will also be there to peddle their influence and kill any home owner efforts to end/limit this fee.
Friday, September 12, 2014
HOA complaint resolution requires HOA homeowner involvement
Silence is not golden! Seems that too many Homeowners Association (HOA) home owners can get long on complaints but short on acting on their concerns. If you have/had an HOA complaint or feel you’ve been wronged by your HOA Board or property management company (PMC) you’re not alone but you must be heard. The State HOA Office and your State representatives have received thousands of HOA complaints over the past two years. This represents but a fraction of HOA complaints.
HOA home owner apathy is no different than in our general population. What drives apathy in HOA disputes is an inability of home owners to successfully exercise their rights. In Colorado we have many HOA laws and nearly two-thirds of our population live under HOA governance. Home owners encountering problems and simply trying to get their HOA to comply with their own governing documents quickly find out that what is in the law and their by-laws is not always enforceable from the home owners perspective. The number one reason for our HOA laws being basically unenforceable is that they all lack a viable, affordable, and accessible means for dispute resolution except our costly, time consuming, litigious, and “pay to play” court system. This dilemma on HOA governance increases home owner apathy and disengagement but doesn’t dampen individual disenchantment with the HOA living concept.
The solution to enforcement of HOA home owner rights rests with implementing an out of court binding dispute resolution process. A process that is affordable and accessible and has a definite beginning (filing a complaint) and end (a decision). Such a process was recently passed into law for HOA home owner complaints with PMCs that will go into law in July 2015. This process is also used when filing complaints against licensed professions in the State via the Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA). Why not for HOA home owner complaints?
The State of Colorado completed a study that identified out of court binding dispute resolution for home owner complaints. This process would handle 95% of home owner complaints that involved non-compliance with HOA law and HOA governing documents but not be applicable to felony cases or those over a certain dollar limit in damages. Home owners could still opt to go to court vs this process and thus no one’s legal rights to a court case are forfeited. The process levels the playing field by not requiring lawyers and costly court proceedings, decides cases on current HOA law and HOA governing documents not legal maneuvers in court, allows for home owners to have their “day in court”, provides no advantage to those with financial resources, keeps frivolous complaints out of court, saves home owners and HOAs in court costs, and provides finality to complaints. It is the solution to HOA complaints.
Implementation of an out of court binding dispute resolution process only awaits legislator sponsors in the upcoming Colorado legislative session. I can assure you that those opposed to reform such as the Community Association Institute (CAI), property managers, and HOA lawyers are already at work with their lobbyists, lawyers, and financial influence to stop such HOA reform in Colorado.
Our organization, Colorado HOA Forum, knows your State legislators are finally beginning to understand HOA issues from the home owner’s perspective. They know what should be done but to date have no done it. In the past, legislators only listened to well paid lobbyist such as the CAI to craft legislation and pursue HOA issues. Of course this ensures nothing changes. HOA home owners must contact their legislators asking them to support the State HOA study and implement an out of court binding dispute resolution process. This can easily be done by visiting the Colorado HOA Forum’s web site.
HOA home owner apathy is no different than in our general population. What drives apathy in HOA disputes is an inability of home owners to successfully exercise their rights. In Colorado we have many HOA laws and nearly two-thirds of our population live under HOA governance. Home owners encountering problems and simply trying to get their HOA to comply with their own governing documents quickly find out that what is in the law and their by-laws is not always enforceable from the home owners perspective. The number one reason for our HOA laws being basically unenforceable is that they all lack a viable, affordable, and accessible means for dispute resolution except our costly, time consuming, litigious, and “pay to play” court system. This dilemma on HOA governance increases home owner apathy and disengagement but doesn’t dampen individual disenchantment with the HOA living concept.
The solution to enforcement of HOA home owner rights rests with implementing an out of court binding dispute resolution process. A process that is affordable and accessible and has a definite beginning (filing a complaint) and end (a decision). Such a process was recently passed into law for HOA home owner complaints with PMCs that will go into law in July 2015. This process is also used when filing complaints against licensed professions in the State via the Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA). Why not for HOA home owner complaints?
The State of Colorado completed a study that identified out of court binding dispute resolution for home owner complaints. This process would handle 95% of home owner complaints that involved non-compliance with HOA law and HOA governing documents but not be applicable to felony cases or those over a certain dollar limit in damages. Home owners could still opt to go to court vs this process and thus no one’s legal rights to a court case are forfeited. The process levels the playing field by not requiring lawyers and costly court proceedings, decides cases on current HOA law and HOA governing documents not legal maneuvers in court, allows for home owners to have their “day in court”, provides no advantage to those with financial resources, keeps frivolous complaints out of court, saves home owners and HOAs in court costs, and provides finality to complaints. It is the solution to HOA complaints.
Implementation of an out of court binding dispute resolution process only awaits legislator sponsors in the upcoming Colorado legislative session. I can assure you that those opposed to reform such as the Community Association Institute (CAI), property managers, and HOA lawyers are already at work with their lobbyists, lawyers, and financial influence to stop such HOA reform in Colorado.
Our organization, Colorado HOA Forum, knows your State legislators are finally beginning to understand HOA issues from the home owner’s perspective. They know what should be done but to date have no done it. In the past, legislators only listened to well paid lobbyist such as the CAI to craft legislation and pursue HOA issues. Of course this ensures nothing changes. HOA home owners must contact their legislators asking them to support the State HOA study and implement an out of court binding dispute resolution process. This can easily be done by visiting the Colorado HOA Forum’s web site.
Your Voice: HOA fees: it’s not the amount but the value and justification
Two thirds of Colorado residents live under Homeowners Association (HOA) governance. All live under covenants, controls, and restrictions and are assessed dues and fees in return for community provided services and amenities. Amounts vary and so do the range and quality of service. Dissatisfaction arises when the value of services for fees is not in line with home owner expectations and/or the justification for fees is poorly supported and can’t be contested. So what causes this misconnect between expectation and delivery.
Problems can occur when HOA home buyers/owners are unaware of what services are to be provided by the HOA. Providing this information to home owners prior to closing on the sale of a home and having buyers certify they read it should be a legal requirement. Problems also occur when HOAs mismanage funds resulting in an inability to provide services at a quality level. This includes not funding HOA reserve funds for planned maintenance, using intended maintenance funds inappropriately on Board special projects or on costly and mostly avoidable law suits, over paying and not competing contract work, and just poor financial planning and management with no oversight or accountability. Then there is the problem of HOA dues being too low for too long to deliver services. Another significant and less discussed problem relates to the lack of oversight and control over the property management companies (PMC). In most HOAs, the PMC runs the community and yes this is the tail wagging the financial dog with little oversight or disclosure to home owners. One more but necessarily the last problem is that HOA Boards have almost zero accountability and unlimited authority in making financial decisions for the community without apprising or with the approval of home owners. This includes raising HOA dues, making special assessments, embarking on high cost law suits, and funding special and high cost projects all without home owner approval or having to justify their actions to home owners.
Then there are fees assessed HOA home owners by PMCs that are not in any HOA documents or approved by HOA Boards. For example, the HOA Transfer Fee. This fee is NOT imposed by, determined by, or retained by the HOA but pocketed by the PMC upon the sale of a home in an HOA. No justification or legal requirement is given, the amount is arbitrary ranging from $100 to over $1,000, can’t be negotiated, must be paid or you can’t sell your home, and worst of all you don’t know about the fee until the closing on your home.
HOA fees and financial accountability are an ongoing problem for HOA home owners. Although Colorado has many HOA laws they all lack an ability to hold the HOA Board and/or PMC accountable for financial mismanagement, reckless behavior, or to provide quality services. The laws lack mandates for home owner involvement and approval on spending HOA funds. Home owners are left paying the fees and assessments unless they choose to challenge the HOA in our costly, litigious, time consuming, “pay to play” court system and most simply can not afford this venue. The good news is that most HOAs and PMCs operate with a good degree of integrity but when bad apples arise the financial consequences can be catastrophic and costly to home owners. Until our State laws are modified to empower home owners with a means (out of court binding dispute resolution process) to hold HOA Boards and PMCs accountable home owners will remain vulnerable to financial abuse and unexpected financial obligations.
Problems can occur when HOA home buyers/owners are unaware of what services are to be provided by the HOA. Providing this information to home owners prior to closing on the sale of a home and having buyers certify they read it should be a legal requirement. Problems also occur when HOAs mismanage funds resulting in an inability to provide services at a quality level. This includes not funding HOA reserve funds for planned maintenance, using intended maintenance funds inappropriately on Board special projects or on costly and mostly avoidable law suits, over paying and not competing contract work, and just poor financial planning and management with no oversight or accountability. Then there is the problem of HOA dues being too low for too long to deliver services. Another significant and less discussed problem relates to the lack of oversight and control over the property management companies (PMC). In most HOAs, the PMC runs the community and yes this is the tail wagging the financial dog with little oversight or disclosure to home owners. One more but necessarily the last problem is that HOA Boards have almost zero accountability and unlimited authority in making financial decisions for the community without apprising or with the approval of home owners. This includes raising HOA dues, making special assessments, embarking on high cost law suits, and funding special and high cost projects all without home owner approval or having to justify their actions to home owners.
Then there are fees assessed HOA home owners by PMCs that are not in any HOA documents or approved by HOA Boards. For example, the HOA Transfer Fee. This fee is NOT imposed by, determined by, or retained by the HOA but pocketed by the PMC upon the sale of a home in an HOA. No justification or legal requirement is given, the amount is arbitrary ranging from $100 to over $1,000, can’t be negotiated, must be paid or you can’t sell your home, and worst of all you don’t know about the fee until the closing on your home.
HOA fees and financial accountability are an ongoing problem for HOA home owners. Although Colorado has many HOA laws they all lack an ability to hold the HOA Board and/or PMC accountable for financial mismanagement, reckless behavior, or to provide quality services. The laws lack mandates for home owner involvement and approval on spending HOA funds. Home owners are left paying the fees and assessments unless they choose to challenge the HOA in our costly, litigious, time consuming, “pay to play” court system and most simply can not afford this venue. The good news is that most HOAs and PMCs operate with a good degree of integrity but when bad apples arise the financial consequences can be catastrophic and costly to home owners. Until our State laws are modified to empower home owners with a means (out of court binding dispute resolution process) to hold HOA Boards and PMCs accountable home owners will remain vulnerable to financial abuse and unexpected financial obligations.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)